Thursday, 15 December 2011

Thursday

A productive day today. Sorted out chapter 2 as far as I can without chapters 1 and 3 and the bits of chapter 2 that my co-author has been promising for months. Revised the first half of chapter 5 but changing the second half  will be the tricky bit - again, because I haven't yet seen chapter 4.

Avoided looking at my email but when I finally succumbed found some further interesting reading for the pile - the latest publication from the FRC about the Combined Code and the Stewardship Code and a nice note from my FRC friend. This report had prompted some of the people on LinkedIn to pontificate about the need for increased regulation and monitoring which irritated me and I wasted some time pointing out the error of their ways. I must reset the way I get messages from LI so that I am not regularly alerted to their idiocies. In a thread on women on boards, it appears that messages have got personal and people have taken offence.

I've received an electronic Xmas card from a friend at MBS and have been forwarded one from Warwick. Both would be mildly entertaining for a child of 5. I wonder why the marketing departments at these universities think this type of greeting is appropriate. And now I see that ICAEW are holding a competition for staff to design ecards: why would a professional body want electronic Valentine's Day cards?

More work on chapter 5 tomorrow. And I must finish with the PhD thesis too.

Monday, 12 December 2011

Tuesday

Monday was spent catching up with colleagues, mostly receiving and passing on information. Annie Pye's ESRC study of boards was reported in the Telegraph and the FT and led to some discussion in the Board Advisors group on LinkedIn. I'm looking forward to reading her study, it's been a huge effort for her with a serious setback initially due to ill health. We exchanged emails and I hope to catch up with her in the new year - we've discussed a project looking at the role of the company secretary and I'd still like to do that, the opportunity to work with her would be very good.

My inbox tells me this has to be a reading week, rather than a writing one. For the REF audit I have to read several papers published by colleagues in journals that do not appear in the ABS list and decide where they would sit in the ranking. This is so subjective that it seems quite pointless to me, especially when the topics are ones with which I am not familiar. The Belgian PhD student, Diane, has sent the final draft of her thesis for approval before submission so that will need careful attention, and then a trip to Louvain in February for her public defence. I am really interested to see how the Belgian process works but the Louvain campus is a bleak place at the best of times, let alone February...

Today we are interviewing for the post doc posts. We have a couple of candidates for our department, one who looks outstanding on paper.

(Later) The interviews were very interesting. Sitting on panels with colleagues always is, I learn more about them than about the interviewees sometimes. The first candidate came over very well but it would have been quite difficult to link her interests into our departmental plans. The second candidate was excellent and would be very good to work with: his background is political science and I can see he'll be a future MP (if the Lib Dems ever recover from the coalition). Hope he turns out to be one of the top five and that he accepts the post if it's offered.

Very good article in the Guardian http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/dec/12/britain-ruled-by-banks
Looked up the CRESC site and found a paper by Julie Froud et al which underpins the book and article - they have written excellent critical stuff on corporate governance so this should be a good read. Added to the pile...

Managed to plough through papers written by colleagues and come up with some kind of categorisation for the audit. Agreed some dissertation marks.

Snowed this afternoon, big wet flakes but they didn't settle. This time last year we were snowed in. Freddie has had his collar taken off and is a happy cat.

More meetings tomorrow and then two clear days for writing, barring domestic disasters...

Sunday, 11 December 2011

Sunday evening

Have just about caught up with myself. Thursday was full of domestic crises but in between I managed to get to London for lunch with my most erudite and charming friend, followed by an event hosted by ICAS and BDO on principles-based accounting standards. I was distinctly underwhelmed by the head of the IASB who said that the IASB doesn't know who its audience is but that doesn't matter because there is only a single economic reality. I thought that standards were an attempt to reconcile different economic realities. I strongly suspected that he didn't know what he was talking about - I assume that he got the job because he is politically adept but I do wonder what David Tweedie might think about his successor. Later I had an interesting chat with two institutional investors who bemoaned the demise of the prudence principle and the notion of stewardship. If that's the approach to financial reporting that investors want, the IASB seems to be way off beam.

No chance to sort out revisions to book chapters, lots of emails to deal with. The LinkedIn discussions about board gender diversity are beginning to irritate me - too many consultants who think that correlation implies causation. I've posted a list of papers selected from my literature search but I doubt whether any of them will bother to read them. If your livelihood depends on trying to promote female appointments, you're not likely to be very open-minded about academic research which raises questions about the consequences, are you?

The highlight of the coming week may be the interviews for the post doc posts, we've had two very good applications and I'm looking forward to meeting the candidates.

Wednesday, 7 December 2011

Wednesday evening

The trip to Cambridge was frustrating but ultimately quite productive. My co-author had very little down on paper but seemed to have enough of an idea in her head about what she is going to write to go through the pile of stuff I have written and help me to reorganise it more coherently. She does seem to be making very heavy weather of it all, though. Early on in the project when it became clear that the archivist had done a lousy job, only part of the papers had been digitised and the keywords for searching the site were very limited, I arranged for the son of a friend who was at a loose end to transfer all the details from the site into a spreadsheet with direct links to the site for the digitised material. I've found this really useful because it's much more easily searchable and the direct links make it very easy to use. But she obviously hasn't used it at all and on our research trips has photocopied a great deal of material unnecessarily when she could have just downloaded it.

The library in Cambridge is very over-heated and there were too many sniffing students. The hotel was less comfortable than on previous trips - my room was on two levels with a staircase in the middle which was a bit disconcerting and although there was a very fancy coffee maker on the desk it took me some time to locate the tea making facilities, in the wardrobe...

I am very pleased to be home, in spite of the huge number of emails waiting for my attention. I've been catching up with the tweets and LinkedIn messages - some worthwhile discussions about NEDs to follow up. Some of my online pals seem to be able to read huge amounts of stuff very quickly and I really can't keep up. The Canadian professor is on sabbatical which explains why he has time for all this reading.

But I shall leave everything for now to spend some time with Freddie who has had an eye operation and is wearing a "lampshade" so keeps bumping into things because he can't feel his whiskers.

Friday, 2 December 2011

Friday

A very tedious week all told, much time spent dealing with problematic colleagues and little writing.

The Scholarly Connections meeting went well although not many came. We heard about a variety of projects and it was good to know that one was sparked off by a previous meeting.

Having suggested to the author of the very long paper that he should send the abstract off to a journal editor, was pleased to discover that this advice had been followed and the editor had made some very perceptive comments, although I had to interpret them for the author. If he follows them up, he could produce a very good paper but it needs a lot of work because the ideas need to be knitted in to the existing literature properly and it's a literature that is new to him.

Reluctantly attended the RKTC meeting with the 24 item agenda. Made some observations but left early. There is a battle to be fought about conference budgets but I don't have the energy at the moment. Our incoming acting head is very much on the ball and it will be good to work with her - I don't think we'll always agree but we have a similar outlook on what's important. The post will be advertised again in the new year but I can't imagine that we'll see a flood of applications. Looks as if I'll be spending quite a bit of time on interview panels this month, with an SL/PL post to fill and post docs, as well as a potential PhD student.

Have read more of Derman's "Models Behaving Badly". Struggled through the physics to his discussion of financial models. Must ask Yuval if he has read it - I think Donald Mackenzie's sociological approach is much more readable because he provides so much more context. I'm quite prepared to be convinced that financial models and theories are not like those in physics but Derman's argument isn't very clear, in my view. But I haven't finished the book yet, perhaps all will become clear at the end. Then I can get back to Kahneman.

Busy weekend ahead, getting organised to go to Cambridge next week. Hope we really can make good progress on the book, much depends on whatever my co-author has managed to write. Second dose of Simon Russell Beale this week last night - watched "Collaborators" at the cinema, live from the NT. Amazing play and very thought-provoking.


Wednesday, 30 November 2011

Wednesday lunchtime


I am far too easily distracted. Yesterday a friend who manages to keep up to date much more quickly than I do kindly alerted me (thanks, Ruth!) to a very recent example of a misreporting of the Cadbury Committee origins, in the recent report of the High Pay Commission. The report attributed the origins of both Cadbury and Greenbury government action. Irritated, I shot off this letter to the editor of the FT and to the chair of the HPC, Deborah Hargreaves.
The High Pay Commission report inaccurately describes the origins of both the Committee on the Financial Aspects of Corporate Governance, chaired by Sir Adrian Cadbury (not Lord Cadbury, as the HPC report describes him) and of the Study Group on Directors' Remuneration,  chaired by Sir Richard Greenbury . Neither initiative was prompted by government action. The first was sponsored by  the Financial Reporting Council, the London Stock Exchange and the Bank of England. The second was set up by the CBI.
In interpreting the reports produced by interest groups, it is important to be aware of their origins. The FT editorial on 21 November ("Managing high pay in companies") notes that the HPC has the support of the Joseph Rowntree Trust but omits the equally important fact that it was established by the pressure group Compass.
I doubt whether I shall receive any acknowledgement but it made me feel better and will get a footnote in the book. I also copied it to Adrian who replied in his usual courteous fashion and pointed out that another frequent erroneous statement is that the committee was set up in response to the Maxwell case.
I then spent some time looking at my NED paper to see how I need to update it from last year - I've discovered some useful literature since then. I wanted to write a new paper looking at the limitations of mandating board composition, incorporating some of the diversity literature, but I won't have time to do that before mid January when the abstract for the conference in Verona in April has to be submitted so I shall recycle the NED one. I might get the new one done in time for the EIASM workshop in May - I expect I could get away with a very rough draft for that, since I am co-chairing!
Most of this morning has been taken up with trying to sort out the story behind the way the case of the student with a dissertation resit has been handled. Our job vacancy has finally appeared on the university website so I alerted a potential external candidate. It seems that her university is being significantly affected by demonstrations associated with today's public sector strike action. Unsurprisingly, our bins haven't been emptied.
Now to make a start on chapter 7...

Monday, 28 November 2011

Monday

Marked two more undergraduate dissertations. One was on the future of audit after the financial crisis which was very confused, mixing US, UK and Australian sources willy-nilly and with a methods section which referred to data collection using interviews and questionnaires of which there was no sign. This was from a student I had supervised, if you can call it that: a single meeting and some sporadic emails. I checked back to see what advice I had given: it had been ignored. The referencing was so bad that I was quite sure that some of his work had been plagiarised so spent some time googling random sentences. Found some of his sources but although the wording was very close he had obviously tried to put it into his own words so decided to give him the benefit of the doubt.

In the course of this investigation, found an interesting paper about Prem Sikka and his work. Realised that some of our younger colleagues may never have come across Prem so sent it round to the whole department.

The other dissertation was about creative accounting, equally confused, claiming to be a case study of Enron but with only half a page about Enron.

This probably wasn't a good time to turn to my colleague's very long conceptual paper.The ideas are interesting but it's not written clearly. I didn't have the energy to edit it but suggested that the abstract could be sent off to a journal editor to enquire as to whether it would be suitable for that journal. And that the paper could be reduced in length by 40%. I won't be popular.

Continuing email conversations with the rogue colleague who persists in submitting funding bids without giving me time to consider whether to approve them. His area of work is very distant from the rest of us and I need to seek expert advice but he leaves everything to the last minute, possibly in the hope that I will just sign without asking any questions.

Read two applications for post-doc posts, one very poorly put together, the other almost too good to be true.

Read some of the papers for the meeting with the 24 item agenda.

Went to the cinema to see "The Deep Blue Sea". Excellent film. Made up for a day swamped with dealing with unproductive things, apart from the occasional email that made me laugh. Not enough of those.