Cats woke me up early on Saturday but wouldn't let me concentrate so tidied up my PC desktop. Realised I now have four folders entitled "interesting papers" for 2011 and the three previous years. At some point I shall have to trawl through those files and see if they really are interesting... If I had been organised enough to set up Zotero or similar software properly it would probably be much easier but I think it's too late now.
Wrote another chunk of just under 1000 words for the book. This could be a preface or a conclusion. It spells out exactly what we intend to do in the book - I have a clearer idea now, before we started I didn't think that the archive would provide enough material so I expected to have two chapters on subsequent developments. But chapter 5 which looks at the response to the Code has become so long and my co-author (who is supposed to write the final chapter) is so slow that I think it would be more sensible to finish the story in 1995 which is really where the archive ends, making the final chapter a brief survey of Adrian's subsequent work, the reflections of the people involved, based on our interviews and some later publications, the committees and reports that followed and the overall influence of the Code but fairly superficially. Chapter 7 will look more closely at "comply or explain", linking up with some of the academic literature. If I could write 1000 words a day it would all be done by Xmas...
I wanted to make the point about the misreporting of the Committee's origins - the Larcker and Tayan book, which is otherwise very good, says that the UK parliament set it up (I wrote to them pointing out that this was wrong and they replied to say that they would correct it in any subsequent edition). So I thought I'd search Google Books to see if I could find any other examples. There were quite a few. And a paper published by Dahya et al in 2002 has been reprinted in several collections and is widely cited - its first line is “The Cadbury Committee was appointed by the
Conservative Government of the United Kingdom in May 1991.”
Interesting email from the solicitor I met at the House of Lords do. We have been discussing the role of NEDs - he is an expert on directors' duties and has a very academic bent. He has sent me details of a current case to read - another item for my tottering pile.
Our faculty research director has sent out an agenda for next Friday's meeting with 24 items! I have tried without success to get him to group the items into those that need discussion and those that are for information only. He is remarkably resistant to this idea but has instead gone through the items telling me why each is essential. It would be much more helpful to have this detail on the agenda itself. It doesn't look as if there is much to discuss at this meeting so maybe it will be over quickly but there is a big danger that among all the papers, which really only need rubber-stamping before sending up to the next level, there is an issue that someone will pick on and make a meal of (I've even been known to do that myself!). If the agenda is properly constructed, this can be prevented. No-one has any training in chairing meetings and we waste a huge amount of time in them. An obsession with bureaucracy reflects a culture of blame-placing and a lack of thoughtful leadership. It is much easier to focus on, for example, documenting a detailed response to the student satisfaction scores than looking at the bigger picture to identify the broader influences on student satisfaction (and in particular the negative aspects of the restructuring which people are happy to expand on anecdotally but no-one seems interested in examining using hard evidence).
Enough ranting for a Monday morning...
Saturday, 26 November 2011
Friday, 25 November 2011
Friday
Husband's new job meant a very early start for him. I had some really good ideas for the book in that dozy time before you really wake up but didn't get round to writing them down soon enough so now they're lost forever <sigh>. Went into work first thing to say hello to Mike Wallace and Alison Wray who are running their excellent course on critical reading and writing today at my suggestion. Anxious moment when they appeared to be late but had in fact been misdirected. Collected a book from the library and stopped for chat with the librarians.
Returned home to write but was distracted by discussion on LinkedIn about the notice of BSkyB's AGM - the date doesn't include the year and someone was asking if this meant it was invalidated. Rang colleague at ICAEW who was a company secretary to check (she said probably not if the full date was included in the other associated material) and had a lengthy chat with her about corporate governance issues, and cats.
By this time it was lunchtime and I got stuck into a cheese sandwich and Daniel Kahneman's new book "Thinking, Fast and Slow" which is fascinating and full of little tests for the reader from his experimental research, to demonstrate how our minds work. I am always keen to read about *how* people conduct research - what sparks off the question, how they decide to investigate it, what problems they have and how they solve them - it's often much more interesting than the actual outcomes of the research. The book I picked up at the library is "Models Behaving Badly: why confusing illusion with reality can lead to disaster on Wall Street and in Life" - I hope it lives up to the promise of the title! (In case anyone is actually reading this - hi, Emma and Maja! - I do read potboilers too and I am greatly enjoying Jo Nesbo's Nemesis on my e-reader)
An email from our research manager reminds me that there will be less attractive reading ahead shortly for the REF audit - looks as if I shall be reading papers by colleagues in economics and information management which could be challenging. And of course I still have that 11,000 word paper and the four dissertations sitting on my desk.... Better get on with it...
Returned home to write but was distracted by discussion on LinkedIn about the notice of BSkyB's AGM - the date doesn't include the year and someone was asking if this meant it was invalidated. Rang colleague at ICAEW who was a company secretary to check (she said probably not if the full date was included in the other associated material) and had a lengthy chat with her about corporate governance issues, and cats.
By this time it was lunchtime and I got stuck into a cheese sandwich and Daniel Kahneman's new book "Thinking, Fast and Slow" which is fascinating and full of little tests for the reader from his experimental research, to demonstrate how our minds work. I am always keen to read about *how* people conduct research - what sparks off the question, how they decide to investigate it, what problems they have and how they solve them - it's often much more interesting than the actual outcomes of the research. The book I picked up at the library is "Models Behaving Badly: why confusing illusion with reality can lead to disaster on Wall Street and in Life" - I hope it lives up to the promise of the title! (In case anyone is actually reading this - hi, Emma and Maja! - I do read potboilers too and I am greatly enjoying Jo Nesbo's Nemesis on my e-reader)
An email from our research manager reminds me that there will be less attractive reading ahead shortly for the REF audit - looks as if I shall be reading papers by colleagues in economics and information management which could be challenging. And of course I still have that 11,000 word paper and the four dissertations sitting on my desk.... Better get on with it...
Thursday, 24 November 2011
Thursday
Thursday again, they come round very quickly...
Today I have written 933 words of the book which I feel quite pleased with. I've been struggling with a structural problem - chapter 5 is far too long and overflows into chapter 6 but I can't work out how to rearrange the material sensibly. This has been preventing me from getting on with the later part of the story so I decided to just start a new document and write, in the hope that it will all fit together properly in the end. I think I'm ready to start on chapter 7 now, which will be more thematic, drawing on the earlier descriptive part. It also moves away from the archive and into the commentary in the academic literature and will include some of the interview material. With a bit of luck and a following wind I should be able to make good progress as I have some clear days ahead.
I've managed to keep my inbox clear too. Some interesting discussion on LinkedIn about the EU consultation on corporate governance which put me back in touch with Sarah Wilson from Manifest who I haven't seen for a while. She sent me their report on "Say on Pay" around the world. In another LinkedIn group, discussion about the High Pay Commission report where I interjected my thoughts on workers on boards, although I haven't of course had a chance to read the HPC report yet! A tweet from my friend at Cranfield about a paper on board diversity which looked at first glance to be the paper I'm planning to write! A moment of panic before I realised that I've seen an earlier draft of this paper on SSRN and it isn't very good.
A lengthy revised literature review from a PhD student which I dealt with by filing it and telling him he could return to it when he has written up his data analysis chapter. Postponed our next meeting until January to give him time to do that.
Two enquiries about doctoral study: one from an MBA student who didn't give any indication of the area of corporate governance she might be interested in but asked me to suggest things to read, and another with a very scrappy proposal attached. If, as he claimed, he had read the web pages he would know that we won't be accepting further applications until next September and that they have to be in specified areas.
Then a colleague emailed an application for central funding to support research impact. My blood pressure soared when I read that he would be away between now and the application deadline and he asked me and the research manager to submit it for him. And then I remembered that when he had expressed an interest in applying three weeks ago I had emailed him and asked him to let me have a draft so that we could discuss it - but he hadn't replied. The application itself is totally unacceptable - no supporting documents to show that he has in fact received an invitation to undertake the travel he is proposing. I can see that I shall have to spend a great deal of time policing rogue researchers which is not in my job description.
Today I have written 933 words of the book which I feel quite pleased with. I've been struggling with a structural problem - chapter 5 is far too long and overflows into chapter 6 but I can't work out how to rearrange the material sensibly. This has been preventing me from getting on with the later part of the story so I decided to just start a new document and write, in the hope that it will all fit together properly in the end. I think I'm ready to start on chapter 7 now, which will be more thematic, drawing on the earlier descriptive part. It also moves away from the archive and into the commentary in the academic literature and will include some of the interview material. With a bit of luck and a following wind I should be able to make good progress as I have some clear days ahead.
I've managed to keep my inbox clear too. Some interesting discussion on LinkedIn about the EU consultation on corporate governance which put me back in touch with Sarah Wilson from Manifest who I haven't seen for a while. She sent me their report on "Say on Pay" around the world. In another LinkedIn group, discussion about the High Pay Commission report where I interjected my thoughts on workers on boards, although I haven't of course had a chance to read the HPC report yet! A tweet from my friend at Cranfield about a paper on board diversity which looked at first glance to be the paper I'm planning to write! A moment of panic before I realised that I've seen an earlier draft of this paper on SSRN and it isn't very good.
A lengthy revised literature review from a PhD student which I dealt with by filing it and telling him he could return to it when he has written up his data analysis chapter. Postponed our next meeting until January to give him time to do that.
Two enquiries about doctoral study: one from an MBA student who didn't give any indication of the area of corporate governance she might be interested in but asked me to suggest things to read, and another with a very scrappy proposal attached. If, as he claimed, he had read the web pages he would know that we won't be accepting further applications until next September and that they have to be in specified areas.
Then a colleague emailed an application for central funding to support research impact. My blood pressure soared when I read that he would be away between now and the application deadline and he asked me and the research manager to submit it for him. And then I remembered that when he had expressed an interest in applying three weeks ago I had emailed him and asked him to let me have a draft so that we could discuss it - but he hadn't replied. The application itself is totally unacceptable - no supporting documents to show that he has in fact received an invitation to undertake the travel he is proposing. I can see that I shall have to spend a great deal of time policing rogue researchers which is not in my job description.
Wednesday, 23 November 2011
Wednesday
Yesterday was taken up with meetings, some of which required follow-up action. Felt like a wasted day, apart from the Scholarly Connections meeting which went well. A good turnout and two presentations which stimulated quite a lot of discussion. I forgot to collect the coffee machine tokens but people brought their own refreshments. I was delighted to receive a box of fancy macaroons from a colleague who had just come back from visiting our French connections in Dijon: I was less delighted about having to share them... I think the lunchtime slot works better than breakfast so will plan for that in future.
Arrived at work today at 8 am and by 10 am had read through and made detailed comments on the MSc dissertation draft for the student with the medical resit. He writes quite well and he has read a huge amount but in some ways this distracts from the poor structure and lack of theory. Framing the comments positively took a lot of thought. Each student is entitled to 4 hours of my time so he's had more than his fair share. And now four undergraduate dissertations to mark. Sometimes these are better than the MSc ones. One looks very thin indeed, perhaps I'll start with that one.
More meetings, formal and informal, and more listening to complaints and unhappiness. Cheered by a chat with a colleague who now works on the other campus so we hardly ever meet. She is always ready for a laugh, although she has plenty to worry about: her son is a soldier serving in Afghanistan.
The last of my academic advisees finally turned up for a meeting. He seems quite happy with everything although I was a bit worried when he asked me what an accounting standard is. After several weeks of the Accounting & Society module I would have expected him to know. I do wonder what goes on in that module. The module leader has sent me a paper to read. Over 11000 words on principle based accounting standards and judgement. I expect I can cut a good deal of it for him. He has taken on board some of my suggestions about the development of his ideas in this area which is gratifying but I'm not sure that I agree with his argument, on first reading at least.
Read a couple of pre-proposals for ICAEW and finally achieved Nirvana - a completely empty inbox!
Arrived at work today at 8 am and by 10 am had read through and made detailed comments on the MSc dissertation draft for the student with the medical resit. He writes quite well and he has read a huge amount but in some ways this distracts from the poor structure and lack of theory. Framing the comments positively took a lot of thought. Each student is entitled to 4 hours of my time so he's had more than his fair share. And now four undergraduate dissertations to mark. Sometimes these are better than the MSc ones. One looks very thin indeed, perhaps I'll start with that one.
More meetings, formal and informal, and more listening to complaints and unhappiness. Cheered by a chat with a colleague who now works on the other campus so we hardly ever meet. She is always ready for a laugh, although she has plenty to worry about: her son is a soldier serving in Afghanistan.
The last of my academic advisees finally turned up for a meeting. He seems quite happy with everything although I was a bit worried when he asked me what an accounting standard is. After several weeks of the Accounting & Society module I would have expected him to know. I do wonder what goes on in that module. The module leader has sent me a paper to read. Over 11000 words on principle based accounting standards and judgement. I expect I can cut a good deal of it for him. He has taken on board some of my suggestions about the development of his ideas in this area which is gratifying but I'm not sure that I agree with his argument, on first reading at least.
Read a couple of pre-proposals for ICAEW and finally achieved Nirvana - a completely empty inbox!
Monday, 21 November 2011
Monday
The optician said my eyes are fine, which is cheering. Tomorrow, the doctor for my ears. A flurry of bad tempered emails made me ponder on the walk to the opticians through the fog and I have resolved to keep out of the work politics that are depressing me. I do find it difficult to watch people making foolish mistakes when a bit of imagination, responsive listening and careful impression management could preserve the goodwill that's essential to the proper functioning of the organisation. But gone are the days when people set aside their own agendas to pull together. From now on I'm saying nothing and doing nothing unless I'm asked. That should give me time to get on with the book.
Got a bit further with chapter 6. My co-author is laid up with dental problems so although today was our self-imposed deadline for completion of the whole draft I have a bit of breathing space as she hasn't finished her bit either. Reread two papers by Alice Belcher which criticised the compliance report produced by the Cadbury Committee. I think her criticisms were unfounded: the original intention of the compliance report was simply to report data for the successor committee and the papers in the archive indicate that it was only decided to publish it at a later stage when it became clear that it could be useful for companies as a benchmark. But Alice writes very well. She is a high achiever: a chartered accountant before doing a degree and becoming an academic lawyer, with a very young family, who became a professor very quickly.
Set about collecting more information from colleagues for the British Accounting Review Research Register: as usual, some immediate replies from the good guys. This time I'm not chasing anyone (another resolution). I've told them the deadline and if they don't provide the information by then they'll either not be included or included with incomplete information.
Read a draft paper for a colleague. As it's on a tax issue I couldn't make any comment on the content but it was so well written that I actually understood it and learnt something from the exercise. Difficult to get tax research published but this is to be sent to a journal that seems rather more practitioner oriented.
Long list of tasks to do at work tomorrow and a day of almost continuous meetings.
Got a bit further with chapter 6. My co-author is laid up with dental problems so although today was our self-imposed deadline for completion of the whole draft I have a bit of breathing space as she hasn't finished her bit either. Reread two papers by Alice Belcher which criticised the compliance report produced by the Cadbury Committee. I think her criticisms were unfounded: the original intention of the compliance report was simply to report data for the successor committee and the papers in the archive indicate that it was only decided to publish it at a later stage when it became clear that it could be useful for companies as a benchmark. But Alice writes very well. She is a high achiever: a chartered accountant before doing a degree and becoming an academic lawyer, with a very young family, who became a professor very quickly.
Set about collecting more information from colleagues for the British Accounting Review Research Register: as usual, some immediate replies from the good guys. This time I'm not chasing anyone (another resolution). I've told them the deadline and if they don't provide the information by then they'll either not be included or included with incomplete information.
Read a draft paper for a colleague. As it's on a tax issue I couldn't make any comment on the content but it was so well written that I actually understood it and learnt something from the exercise. Difficult to get tax research published but this is to be sent to a journal that seems rather more practitioner oriented.
Long list of tasks to do at work tomorrow and a day of almost continuous meetings.
Sunday, 20 November 2011
Sunday
Friday was a write-off so needed to catch up a bit over the weekend. Cleared much of inbox which included lengthy message form the student who lost his iPhone, bemoaning a mark of 57% in his first assignment on the Academic English module. He lost marks for poor referencing and using Wikipedia. Took the opportunity to explain to him about the authority of sources and why referencing is important: we tend to emphasise the plagiarism aspect without explaining to students that references in what they read are very important too and they should follow them up. Perhaps I should make a podcast on this. Also request from friend to act as referee for a promotion application. I'm happy to do this but the CV enclosed was not very well put together and doesn't really do justice to the application. I've read a lot of CVs lately - I think there is a great art to producing a good one.
Finished reading "Economics of Good and Evil". A very interesting book surveying the history of economics to show how it began with a moral aspect which has been lost in our modern rational and mathematical approach. Starting with the Gilgamesh and Bible (I don't like the rather modern English translation of the verses he cites but he certainly knows it some detail, both Old and New Testaments) and sailing through many great economic philosophers, with footnotes on Terry Pratchett, Stephen Leacock, the Matrix and other modern cultural icons. a very well read individual.
His glancing reference to economics as helmsmanship (p61) resonated with the paper on the ICAEW logo, Economia, that Mike and I wrote. He also makes the point that Smith only referred to "the invisible hand" three times in his work and never developed the idea as it has been subsequently, and the same applied to Keynes' notion of "animal spirits". It seems to me that these are quite startling metaphors and that is why they have become central to debate about economics. He suggests that although economics is presented as scientific and rational "a religious and emotional zeal .. accompanies many schools of economic thought". "We also have a magical incantation for predicting the future; we say ceteris paribus every time....Aside from it sounding like "abracadabra", we must admit that reality tends not to be ceteris paribus." (p307) All of which appeals to my own prejudices!
Can't imagine how a play was made out of the book but that's what it says on the cover. Found him on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_YIKK6taIE His presentation style is very much how the book reads.
Also read an interesting paper by an Israeli academic who analysed meeting minutes for insights into board behaviour. I find this worrying as there is no recognition that minutes are not necessarily an objective record: someone authored them but content analysis does not recognise this contextual issue. (The same applies to analysis of narrative reports in my view. The only people who seem to acknowledge this are those using a visual approach.) She presents minutes analysis as more objective than interviews. Maybe I'll write to her about this.
Finished reading "Economics of Good and Evil". A very interesting book surveying the history of economics to show how it began with a moral aspect which has been lost in our modern rational and mathematical approach. Starting with the Gilgamesh and Bible (I don't like the rather modern English translation of the verses he cites but he certainly knows it some detail, both Old and New Testaments) and sailing through many great economic philosophers, with footnotes on Terry Pratchett, Stephen Leacock, the Matrix and other modern cultural icons. a very well read individual.
His glancing reference to economics as helmsmanship (p61) resonated with the paper on the ICAEW logo, Economia, that Mike and I wrote. He also makes the point that Smith only referred to "the invisible hand" three times in his work and never developed the idea as it has been subsequently, and the same applied to Keynes' notion of "animal spirits". It seems to me that these are quite startling metaphors and that is why they have become central to debate about economics. He suggests that although economics is presented as scientific and rational "a religious and emotional zeal .. accompanies many schools of economic thought". "We also have a magical incantation for predicting the future; we say ceteris paribus every time....Aside from it sounding like "abracadabra", we must admit that reality tends not to be ceteris paribus." (p307) All of which appeals to my own prejudices!
Can't imagine how a play was made out of the book but that's what it says on the cover. Found him on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_YIKK6taIE His presentation style is very much how the book reads.
Also read an interesting paper by an Israeli academic who analysed meeting minutes for insights into board behaviour. I find this worrying as there is no recognition that minutes are not necessarily an objective record: someone authored them but content analysis does not recognise this contextual issue. (The same applies to analysis of narrative reports in my view. The only people who seem to acknowledge this are those using a visual approach.) She presents minutes analysis as more objective than interviews. Maybe I'll write to her about this.
Friday, 18 November 2011
Friday
Realise I've been doing this for a month and chapter 6 still isn't finished... I see that after a small surge of interest, nobody read my blog yesterday. As I'm really only writing it for myself to remind myself of how I've been spending my working time, this doesn't matter but I feel slightly disappointed. I'll get over it. As I will also get over my visit to the dentist which involved major excavation and reconstruction and has left my face completely numb. Strange that it became number after I got home. Feel as if I'm dribbling and as if my nose is running.
Found this in my Google Reader alerts: http://www.phd2published.com/2011/11/18/matt-might-writing-productivity-tips-for-academics/
Conscious that I'm easily distracted while at the PC. I think this is very common -
see http://xkcd.com/862/ and http://blog.xkcd.com/2011/02/18/distraction-affliction-correction-extensio/ (who knew xkcd had a blog? Another thing to read...)
Wonder if I should invest in StayFocusd now that I use Chrome a lot. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/laankejkbhbdhmipfmgcngdelahlfoji
Tried CiteULike to see how it works. Might be worth transferring all those papers in the files on my desktop which are labelled "interesting papers" for every year... I'd need to stop and read them as I went along so it could be very time-consuming. Rather like my plan to search for electronic copies of all the papers in my filing cabinets which were only available in hard copy back in the 1990s: I did get some way into that and cleared some space but I seem to have filled it up again...
So I've now spent an hour thinking about how to be more productive. Not sure that that was a good use of my time but the numbness is still interfering with my concentration.
Sorted out tokens for the coffee machine for next Tuesday's Scholarly Connections meeting - this may be my major achievement today. We're not allowed lunch under new austerity rules (I have no problem with that, the sandwiches are not very nice and a lot get left and thus wasted) but I did think tea and coffee could be possible - apparently not, because it's only a one hour meeting. Reflecting on the meetings I've attended lately, quite a few now seem to be held because they have to within the committee structure and processes of the Faculty and the university, but have very little value that I can see. Information can be communicated in so many more efficient ways and the meetings are not properly run. They are not decision-making bodies,they don't do a very good job of monitoring and most people attending don't understand what their role is. It would be a very interesting project to pull the whole system apart and construct something that was fit for purpose.
Found this in my Google Reader alerts: http://www.phd2published.com/2011/11/18/matt-might-writing-productivity-tips-for-academics/
Conscious that I'm easily distracted while at the PC. I think this is very common -
see http://xkcd.com/862/ and http://blog.xkcd.com/2011/02/18/distraction-affliction-correction-extensio/ (who knew xkcd had a blog? Another thing to read...)
Wonder if I should invest in StayFocusd now that I use Chrome a lot. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/laankejkbhbdhmipfmgcngdelahlfoji
Tried CiteULike to see how it works. Might be worth transferring all those papers in the files on my desktop which are labelled "interesting papers" for every year... I'd need to stop and read them as I went along so it could be very time-consuming. Rather like my plan to search for electronic copies of all the papers in my filing cabinets which were only available in hard copy back in the 1990s: I did get some way into that and cleared some space but I seem to have filled it up again...
So I've now spent an hour thinking about how to be more productive. Not sure that that was a good use of my time but the numbness is still interfering with my concentration.
Sorted out tokens for the coffee machine for next Tuesday's Scholarly Connections meeting - this may be my major achievement today. We're not allowed lunch under new austerity rules (I have no problem with that, the sandwiches are not very nice and a lot get left and thus wasted) but I did think tea and coffee could be possible - apparently not, because it's only a one hour meeting. Reflecting on the meetings I've attended lately, quite a few now seem to be held because they have to within the committee structure and processes of the Faculty and the university, but have very little value that I can see. Information can be communicated in so many more efficient ways and the meetings are not properly run. They are not decision-making bodies,they don't do a very good job of monitoring and most people attending don't understand what their role is. It would be a very interesting project to pull the whole system apart and construct something that was fit for purpose.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)